Showing posts with label speech. Show all posts
Showing posts with label speech. Show all posts

Monday, March 1, 2010

Hope and Wonder

We're in the garden; it's a beautiful Sunday after a torrentially rainy Saturday. Em's helping me weed; N's playing in the dirt, which is somehow supposed to be helping me, but isn't at all. Still, it's making him happy, so it's all good.

Suddenly, a bee buzzes past N's head. He jumps, startles, freaks out. This is what he does when there's a bee. It's OK. He retreats into the house, gathers himself.

A few minutes later, he comes back into the garden.

"Was I ever stung by a bee when I was a baby?" he asks.

"Nope," I answer. "Not that I can think of."

He ponders for a moment. "I hope my friends were stung by a bee when they were a baby," he says. (He's referring to our Sunday Gang of friends, who are on their way over.)

Now I'm startled. "Why would you hope that your friends were stung by a bee?" I asked.

He looks confused, and just as he says it, I get it. "I don't hope that," he says.

"I think you mean you wonder if any of your friends were stung by a bee when they were babies," I say.

"Right," he says. "I wonder."

I wonder if he knew what he'd said. When he heard me repeat the sentence with the word 'hope' in it, he didn't seem to recognize it as his own. But if I hadn't supplied the word 'wonder' for him, he wouldn't have come up with it on his own, not right away.

Still, he knew what he meant; he knew what he meant to say. That's not what I'm worried about. I worry about the fact that, so often, the sentences that come out of his head all mixed up and jumbled sound like real sentences. Like this one. People think he means what he's saying. But his yes can mean no; his up, down; his black, white; his hope, wonder.

I wonder whether I'll ever really get the people who are supposed to help him to see these so-hard-to-see deficits in a reliable way. I wonder whether he'll ever be able to make himself really, truly understood, to find his way to words that don't dance away and around him all the time.

I hope so. I hope he will. It's what keeps me going.

Sunday, November 29, 2009

A Powerful Owie

I walk past N as he puts parmesan on his pasta in the kitchen, his head bent over. I can't resist. I kiss the back of his neck.

"Owie," he says.

"Owie?" I reply. "That didn't hurt."

"But it tickled," he says. "And so I said 'owie.' You can't argue with that."

"Um, yes, I can."

"No, you can't," he says with finality. "Owie's a strong and powerful word."

I'm not sure I know what that conversation meant, but I'm pretty sure it was profound.

Monday, June 30, 2008

Correctness

N has been working on correcting his mispronunciations of late, and it's unbearably cute. For instance...Well, first I have to give a little backstory.

N, with all his sensory issues, is obsessed with chewing gum. He wants to be chewing on a piece of gum ALL THE TIME. I'm OK with that, in theory. But in reality, where he was going through two or three packs of gum a day, I wasn't so OK with that, because it meant I was constantly having to buy more gum. There was never enough in the house. So we instituted a rule: He gets five pieces of bubble gum each day, all at one time, and it's up to him how to use them. Half the time he eats them all in rapid succession and then is stuck with nothing to chew for the rest of the day. But he understands that that's his 'choice', and that he gets no more once they're gone, and he's OK with that. Sort of. He's not happy about it, but he gets it, so at least he doesn't spend the entire rest of the day saying, "Can I have another piece of gum?" "Can you get me some gum?" "I really want some gum!"

This may have been my smartest parenting move of all time. So simple, and yet so effective.

Now that it's summer, he gets his five pieces of gum after breakfast, rather than once school lets out. Which is where the mispronunciations come in. As instructed by his speech therapist, I've been gently pointing out to him the 'right' way to say certain words, by breaking them down into syllables and getting him to say each syllable in its turn. So, when he came and announced to me the other day that he'd had his "brefkist" and would like his gum now, I had him repeat "breck" and "fist" first, then gave him his gum.

Since then, he's decided that in order to get his gum, he has to figure out how to say breakfast first. "Don't give it to me if I say 'I had my brefkist,'" he scolded me the other day as I started to hand over the goods. "Only give it to me when I say, 'I had my BREK FIST.'"

As the days have worn on, he's started adding to the list. "Also, before I get my gum, I have to say 'helicopter' instead of 'heli-hock-ter,'" he informed me yesterday. And then, this morning, "And I also have to say 'vanilla' instead of 'banana.' And 'commercial' instead of 'mercercial.' I have to say ALL those words right to get my gum."

And so he did.

Friday, March 14, 2008

I'll Love You Forever

The kids got out of school early today (report card prep for the teachers) and while Em went to play at a friend's house, N and I went to the library to see if we could find more of Tedd Arnold's Fly Guy books to read. (Any book that makes N say, "Let's get more of these!" gets an immediate response in my house. But we always try the library first. Because...Well, if you don't know why, you obviously didn't read about how I buy Chanukah presents at Goodwill.)

On the way back, we passed a construction site. "When I get to be a grownup, I'm going to work there," N said, pointing. "And then I'll come home at night and sleep in our house still, of course. Except Daddy will have to teach me to drive a car. Or a truck, maybe."

"So you're going to be a construction worker now?" I asked. "What happened to being a fireman?"

"Well, I might have a lot of jobs," he replied. "Like...Well, I don't want to be a soldier, because I don't want to die, but I might be a policeman, a fireman, an ambulance...Wait. Do policemen die?"

"Well, yes, sometimes," I admitted. "And sometimes firemen do, too. Those are all very important jobs, but sometimes they can be dangerous."

"Well, if I was made of metal I wouldn't die," he countered.

"Sure, but if you were made of metal, you'd be a robot and you wouldn't be a human. So you couldn't die, because you wouldn't be alive."

He pondered this for a minute, then moved on. "Where do policemen live?"

"They live in houses with their families, like everyone else," I said. "They go to the police station to do their job, then they come home."

"Good," he answered. "Because I still want to live with you and Daddy and sleep in my favorite bed with Snuggy as my guard." [Note: We really need to work on his pronounciation of 'guard,' because right now it comes out as 'god,' and it always takes me aback to hear him proclaim, when Snug settles down on the foot of his bed as he does every night, "Oh, good. There's Snuggy, my god."]

"Don't you want to live somewhere else when you grow up?"

"No way! Except..." and here he hesitates for a second, "well, one day I might see a girl I like and marry her."

"Right. And then what will you do?"

"It'll be OK, though. I'll just talk to her about it a lot and then we'll both live with you guys."

"In your same bed? With the Spongebob sheets?"

"In my favorite bed. With my favorite Spongebob sheets. And Snuggy as our god."

It's good to have a plan.

[Note number 1: I swear to Snuggy that this is an almost word-for-word transcript of what transpired. Check out those language skills. Note how the entire thing makes almost perfect sense. It would be almost freaky if it weren't so wonderful.]

[Note number 2: I swear to Snuggy as well that I have NO idea where he got the "I don't want to be a soldier because I don't want to die," thing. You'd think it would be obvious (here everyone looks meaningfully over at Baroy), but that is actually so NOT the kind of thing that ever gets discussed in this house, or at least not with the kids directly. So I haven't a clue, not really.]

Thursday, February 28, 2008

What Normal Sounds Like

"Hey, Dad, do you want to see what I put in my white-and-orange sack?"

"Mommy, I want to read that book called 'The Fire Cat' again."

"We're having Mrs. Nelson for a substitute tomorrow."

Not more than two months ago, maybe less, those sentences would have read as follows:

"Hey, Dad, do you want to see what I put in that thing? That thing! That thing! There! That thing THERE!" [A tantrum follows.]

"Mommy, I want to read that book again. That book with the thing? The animal thing? NO, not THAT BOOK! The OTHER BOOK! NO NOT THAT ONE!" [A tantrum follows.]

"We're having a substitute yesterday. That teacher I like? That girl? The one we had next month? That OTHER GIRL! THE ONE WE HAD ANOTHER DAY!" [A tantrum follows.]

I have no idea what has changed. He started speech therapy at around the time that Baroy and I started REALLY noticing a huge difference in his language skills, but I mean literally started. Like had his first or second sessions. No way the speech therapist deserves all the credit for this one. Though, hey, if it means this period of enhanced speech development keeps up, then I'll give it to her.

It's amazing, though, how much harder it is to notice 'normal' than it is to notice 'disordered.' It really just sort of dawned on us, slowly, that we were starting to understand him more often, without interpretation, without context. These examples above stood out because of how exceptional they are in their specificity. I mean, before, he wouldn't have even been able to express that he was talking about what he put in a 'sack,' much less think to describe the COLOR of the sack, to make it easier for the person listening to him to know what he's talking about. And the fact that he's not only getting temporal references right, but he remembered the name of a substitute teacher he had...that's remarkable, considering that he has regularly had trouble recalling the names of two of the three women we see EVERY WEEK, who he has known since he was born, who he adores, and at whose homes he has slept over many times.

I am, I must say, absolutely flabbergasted. And thrilled. And excited to see what comes next.

Sunday, January 27, 2008

Malaprop

Em and N are wrestling on the futon couch in our family room. Em gets N in a compromising position, and is lording it over him. When N finally wriggles out, he raises a finger in the air and declares, "You're gonna get paid for that!"

Bwah!

Monday, December 10, 2007

The News Ticker

If misery loves company, my misery is very happy: Viacom freelancers protest

This doctor (mis)treated my stepfather in 2004, robbing him of most of his sight in his left eye. My stepdad's not one of the people mentioned in this piece, so who knows who many people this fool preyed on? There are times when I wish we had a literal eye-for-an-eye justice system. I'd like to personally aim a laser at that guy's retina and burn it out in retribution. I'm guessing my mom would rather it be done more painfully--perhaps with a spoon and without anesthesia?

The report from N's private speech eval came in. There's nothing in there that I didn't know, except for the first time I have a piece of paper that says he has a speech disorder and has a specific diagnostic code next to it. (Now all I need is health insurance...) So that's good. Besides, who can complain about an evaluation that calls your kid "a sweet, charming and delightful little boy"? I'll provide more detail later, but suffice it to say it says everything I'd hoped it would say.

Monday, November 26, 2007

Naming

My Aunt Barbara has been staying with us for the last week-and-a-bit, on and off. She lives in Florida, and it's been a couple of years since my kids have seen her at all. They're like pigs in slop with all the attention they're getting--little consumer-driven, Aunt-Barbara-wants-to-spoil-us-rotten-and-we're-not-going-to-complain pigs.

N, especially, has been loving having Aunt Barbara here, because she's actually been playing with him--or, more specifically, watching his many activities and submitting to being bossed around by a not-yet-7-year-old who seems to have the bossing abilities of a man many years his senior.

[You're going to have to forgive me here, by the way. I've spent the last 20 minutes trying to figure out just how to make this into a cohesive story rather than a series of only loosely related sentences, and I just can't make it hang together. But I still want to say what I want to say. So please ignore the utter and complete lack of transitions. Or don't ignore them, but at least try to forgive them. Thank you for your cooperation. Sincerely, The Management]

One of N's 'quirks' is his extreme difficulty with names. There are people he's known for years whose names he still has trouble with...people he's known since he was BORN. Given time and hints, he'll get it...but it's a definite weakness he'll likely have to deal with all his life.

Thus it was not much of a surprise to me that he's been continually getting stalled this week when trying to get Aunt Barbara's attention. (Like most people, Aunt Barbara balks at responding to "Hey, you!") He's gotten better and better over time at covering for himself...my favorite this week was when he tried to ask me when Aunt Barbara was coming back from her friend's house where she stayed for a couple of nights, and wound up asking, "When will...um...uh...you know...our aunt be coming home?" Our aunt. Couldn't you just smush him up and eat him with brown sugar and butter melted on top?

Now, all of this is complicated by the fact that many, many years back--for reasons we have been debating on and off all week--I began calling my Aunt Barbara AB. (Short for, you know, Aunt Barbara. In case that was confusing anyone. Yes, feel free to despise me now for talking down to you.) Em has picked that up as well, but N had only ever referred to her as Aunt Barbara. Which only worsened the problem of his coming up with her name, since he wasn't hearing it from me or Em. Finally, however, after days and days of stumbling over her name and having to be reminded of what it was and of seeming to be visibly flustered by this problem--one of the first times I've seen him seem to feel badly about not knowing a name--he's finally given up, and has started calling her AB. Which, for some reason, seems unbearably cute and grown-up and yet almost inappropriate--almost disrespectful--coming from him. Still, the cute wins out. As AB said to me today, "I was going to tell him that you have to be a certain age to call me AB, but it's just so adorable coming from him, I can't bring myself to do it."

See? Not only rambling and badly constructed, but pointless as well! A trifecta of Bad Blogging!

This month simply can't end soon enough, can it?

Saturday, November 17, 2007

A Postscript-ish Defense

Everyone's kinda jumping on the poor SLP for saying N's not on the spectrum. So I feel like I should stand up for her--and for me--a bit. What she was saying, in essence, was that he qualifies for and deserves major services, period. For a variety of issues.

She did say, as several of you did, that yes, if I keep looking and asking and pushing, I might get someone to give him a PDD label. But she also implied (and gosh I wish I had a tape recorder so I could put it the very gentle and diplomatic way she did) that anyone who did give him such a label would be doing it because they were either not very good at their job or would be turning a blind eye to the truth in order to help me get what I want. The truth is that, yes, on paper, he's spectrummy, what with the social issues (though they are becoming more and more invisible outside the classroom), the communication issues, the sensory issues. But in person, he simply is not. He's something else...in so many senses of the word. (She mentioned another, possibly more fitting, umbrella label that of course went in and out of my head...something along the lines of Multisomething Developmental Delays maybe?)

[I'm putting aside the 'it's a spectrum' argument for now, because, yes, semantically, everyone is on the spectrum. But 'everyone' doesn't qualify for a label, and 'everyone' doesn't qualify for services. So there's clearly a line over which you're considered to really be 'on' the spectrum rather than off it. Em is way way way off it. N is too, just less so.]

I really do agree with her. As, to be honest, has every single professional who has ever looked at him. I have a folder full of reports from Pediatricians and Developmental Pediatricians and Occupational Therapists and Speech Therapists and Special Education Teams...and on every single one, it says that there is this concern and that concern and the other concern, but they also all say in one way or another that he doesn't meet the criteria. Not even close. This isn't about getting a second opinion. I've had, conservatively, five opinions--and, in reality, closer to eight or ten. And they all say no.

That sounds negative, but she wasn't being negative. She thinks that I have a very strong case to get him an IEP and accommodations WITHOUT a spectrum diagnosis, and she was almost flat-out begging me to go that route. She warned that I would likely need an advocate to help me down the road (which, thanks to my buddy Valle's constant reiteration of the same refrain will be easy to do, since I have a great, huge list of people to contact when the time comes), because she thinks they may balk at it, but also because she thinks we may end up having to ask them to pay for more appropriate speech therapy than they can provide, or for private OT, etc. She also thinks there's a real case to be made for him needing an at-least-part-time one-on-one aide to help him regulate in class.

But before we go there...to advocates, etc...she said she thinks I should start by going in with the simple and straightforward attitude that it is illegal for them to refuse to help him if he qualifies for help--regardless of his label or lack thereof. He has problems that are interfering with his ability to learn...period. Doesn't matter what he's called. He need help, he deserves help, they need to help. FAPE, baby!

And that is something I can fight for without feeling at all like I'm fudging. We'll see how it goes.

How the Assessment Went

Oh, you mean ASIDE from the fact that my kid was drunk? (No, not really, PnP. Chill.) THAT kind of how it went?

It went...Well, wait. How do you determine whether an assessment went well or not? If by 'it went well' you mean they looked at him and looked at me and said, "Pish-posh, nothing wrong here. You're overreacting. Your son is fine. Go home and he will magically be like every other kid, because we said he's fine, you silly," then no. It did not go well. They didn't say anything like that.

But if by well you mean they listened to what Baroy and I had to say and remembered everything I'd said on the phone and then went and spent time with him and came back and told us that yes, everything I think is wrong is really wrong (and I mean REALLY wrong), then yay. It went swimmingly.

There's a report coming that will have words in it that will help me make more sense out of that whole experience. But I can say that there was a lot of 'stuff' we talked about that gave me plenty to mull over in the meantime: Like recognizing that N's deficits are REAL, but they're not in areas that are easily quantifiable, and thus don't show up easily on measured tests, and that's just the way that is. (When you can't pronounce words, that's quantifiable; you can literally count the sounds a child can or cannot make, for instance. But when you have trouble taking your thoughts and translating them into appropriate sentences, that can't be measured.) So it's going to be fight. Like recognizing what 'winning' that fight means at the district level--i.e., I can fight and fight to get him into speech therapy, and I will likely get there with this assessment report in my hand, but that the school-based therapy/therapist is, oh, let's be optimistic and say it's unlikely she will be able to appropriately address his issues, no matter how much therapy she gives him, because this is not her area of expertise. Like recognizing that he is not, not, not likely at all to get an autism spectrum diagnosis (because he's not autistic...or Asperger's...or PDD...and I know that), and how that is not supposed to make a difference (you're not supposed to need a label to get services; you're just supposed to have a demonstrable need, and he does), but that it might. Like recognizing that there still may not be an umbrella label for me to use as a guide through all of this, but that that doesn't mean there isn't a problem. There's a problem.

But, oh, how intense it was to watch professionals at work, and to really see how someone who knows what they're doing can just zero in on an issue and lay it out there. Even *I* had never seen the basic issue laid out there quite so baldly before. (And it was done in such a 'duh' way...so simple. She read him a book, then asked him to tell Baroy and me the story. Even with the book in hand to remind him, he couldn't even come close to making it make sense. "It was dark, and then they...Boom! And more of it. And then he was sick.") Equally fascinating--if fundamentally upsetting to see him that way--was watching N's body while he was doing this task. He was literally bouncing off of the couch, off of me, off of Baroy. Sitting, then jumping up, then switching positions, then throwing his hands in the air, then...It was exhausting and stressful just watching him. Pure anxiety in motion.

Perhaps the most interesting thing the lead therapist (the woman who owns the practice, and who N declared he's going to marry when he's a grownup) brought up was the classic chicken-and-egg question: N has language problems. He has social issues. He has anxiety. He has sensory issues. But which came first? Did his developmental delays in speech lead to his being anxious about interacting with other children, who he has trouble communicating with? Did his anxieties about interacting with other children lead to a delay in speech? Are his sensory issues causing him anxiety? Does he have sensory issues because he's naturally anxious and he uses sensory input to calm his anxiety?

In the end, this isn't going to be critical, but I do wonder in which order these things developed. Because, to some degree, it would help me to know where to start, which angle to attack things from. When you have limited resources of time, money, whatever, it's best to use those resources to attack the root of the problem, rather than just one of its branches. But what is the root?

One thing I am now positively going to INSIST on going forward, though: This kid needs some kind of well-thought-out sensory diet, and he needs it to be implemented at school. After the disaster of the story-retelling, N jumped up from the couch and started telling the therapists to watch how far he could jump; the woman who was interviewing Baroy and me 'made him' jump back and forth across the room three times, and got him to do it in froggy jumps. "He needs that right now," she said. "He just did something that was so hard for him. He needs to let go of some of the anxiety."

Of course. Of course he does. And this is what he must feel like all day, every day, at school. I knew that, but I'd never seen it so clearly before. Of course he needs that. He's being asked to do things all the time that are damned near impossible for him, and he pulls them off, and then...he's asked to do some more of them. And to be quiet about it. And to stay in his seat while he does it. It must be torture. Last year we tried to address that to some degree by getting the teacher to allow him to chew on straws so that he wouldn't chew on his shirts. But now it's time to get accommodations like that written into an IEP or a 504 Plan, if we ultimately fail on the IEP front.

So, um, yeah. That's how the assessment went.

Friday, November 16, 2007

Hair of the Dog

Here's a conversation I wasn't expecting to have this morning. We were leaving the house in a bit of a rush to get to the private speech assessment, and N said he was thirsty, so I told him to go have a quick drink of something and meet me out by the car. Baroy was lagging behind to lock up the house.

N, coming out of the house: What was the funny thing in that soda, Mama?

Me, helping him into the car because he was moving sooooo slowly: What funny thing?

N: In the soda I just drank. It maybe tasted like wine, I think.

Me, getting into the driver's seat: I'm sure it wasn't wine, honey.

N: Well, it tasted like it. It was in that soda can, the red one.

Me, suddenly stopping dead in my tracks, thinking What do we have in the house in a red can? We have diet ginger ale in a white can and diet coke in a gold can and...oh, shit...: Open your mouth and breathe out for me, honey. (A pause.) Holy...

Yup. My not-yet-7-year-old kid knocked back a full swig of beer at 8:30 in the morning. (In his defense, we usually only have beer in bottles, but one of our friends brought over some cans of Tecate the other night, so I'm not surprised he didn't recognize it as off limits.)

And so I dragged him out of the car, brushed his teeth, and washed his face. Because dayum. The kid smelled like a frigging BREWERY. And then spent the ride into Pasadena trying to figure out how to explain this to the speech therapist..."Well, no, actually, the slurring isn't normal for him..."

And that, my friends, was the beginning of my day. How's yours going?

Monday, October 29, 2007

Peers

After the sleepover on Saturday night, I drove the kids to religious school in the morning. Zach and N took a few books about firefighters and fire engines into the car with them, and Zach read them to N.

Moment one: Zach is about six months younger than N, but is reading at a level WAY above most 6-year-olds. To wit, he read sentences that said, "The fire engine speeds through the intersection," and "The firefighters prepare their equipment," without hesitation. N, listening, suddenly says to me, "Mama, Zach is a much better reader than me."

"Yes, he is, sweetie," I replied, still driving. "But soon, with some practice, you'll be able to read those words, too."

"Oh, I know," he replied, and he and Zach bent their heads together to continue the story. "I was just telling you."

Moment two: N points to a picture in the book. "That firefire is climbing a HUGE ladder!"

"It's a fireFIGHTER," Zach replies, emphasizing the t sound in the second half of the word.

"I said firefire," N says, slightly irritated.

I intervene. "Zach, sometimes N has a little trouble with some words, but he was trying to say firefighter."

For several minutes after, N keeps trying the word out, trying to get that pesky T to stay where it's supposed to. It was clearly hard work.

Me, I was sitting there thinking simply, "That's one of the first times ever that someone his own age has corrected his speech," and trying to figure out if that was a good thing, or a bad thing, or...

Moment three: I'll tell you what was an unqualified first and a Very Good Thing, though. Later on Sunday, after I'd driven both boys back to our house (where Zach's mom and dad and a couple of other families from temple joined us for a late lunch and birthday celebration for one of the other kids), N and Zach were on the front porch, and N saw his friend B from across the street and called to him to come over. And then N, Zach, and B went into our backyard and played together for a while--three first-grade boys, connected through N. N, with two different friends, having fun. Thank you, god.

-------
We finally got the assessment plan from the school district on Friday, and as I suspected, it had only speech and OT listed. I'm on a deadline right now (which is why I'm blogging, of course), but as soon as that's done, later today, I'm going to sit down and write a draft letter in response to the plan. My basic idea is that it will say that I do indeed want these assessments to be done and that I give my permission for them, but that I also believe a social/emotional assessment is essential to the process, and to N's success in school. I will then likely add that by diagnosing and suggesting medication for my son in the team meeting last week--before ever meeting him--the school psychologist has removed himself as the person who should be allowed to do that assessment. I will then ask the district to recommend who *they would like to pay* to do such an assessment, since the school psychologist's suggestion in the meeting that I should have him assessed myself (since, you know, I have private insurance) was equally inappropriate.

I am so over these people, I can not even begin to tell you. But I do hope to begin to tell THEM.

Monday, October 22, 2007

Clutching

Em still likes for me to lay down with her at night as she falls asleep. Because N likes this, too, I alternate nights with them. Tonight was Em's night. As she started to drift off, I felt her hand search around under the covers for mine, and then, when she found it, she wrapped her big-girl fingers around my pointer finger and my heart positively splintered with happiness as I was lurched suddenly backwards ten years to when she was a newborn and would hold onto my finger as she breastfed, as she screamed, as she drifted off to sleep, as she began to explore the world.

-------
Today was part one of N's IEP process--the part wherein we discussed what kinds of evaluations need to be done before we can begin to discuss what services he needs in the classroom.

Bottom line: I'm not sure it went well. Actually, I'm half certain that I got fucked. But I don't know for sure, because I was alone, and I can only take so many notes while trying to watch out for the multitude of barriers--however camouflaged--being thrown up in my path with every word I said. (I had to go alone. There was no one other than Baroy available to watch N while we met--at 2:15 in the afternoon, there aren't a lot of babysitters available, and unfortunately, since one of the main points was his SOCIAL ISSUES, I didn't really have the option of sending him home with a friend, you know?)

I'll see tomorrow, when I'm supposed to get the written assessment plan, but I think the only assessments will be for OT and speech...with the latter being given quite reluctantly, to be honest, after the speech therapist talked about having 'chatted informally' with him and seeing issues, but nothing that would likely qualify him for services. That tune changed a bit when I announced (thank GOD things worked out this way...literally two hours before the meeting) that I had made an appointment with one of the top private SLPs in the area for a private assessment in mid-November. There was a bit of frowning around the room after that, and a relatively ham-handed attempt by the school psychologist to totally undermine me. [Him: Do you maybe want to put that assessment off until after you see what our testing has to say? Me (in my head): Why? So you can deny services and then force me to wait another six months or a year before you have to consider the assessment I get? Me (out loud): Oh, she's so booked up, I'm not giving up this appointment! We'll just see if anything she has to say adds to the mix. Can't hurt, right? Him: (Forced laugh.) Speech therapist: Well, then, I'll just make sure to cover everything that might be addressed by your evaluation! It'll save us all time. (What she was planning to cover if I *didn't* have such an eval planned is anyone's guess.)]

[An aside: $400 for a speech assessment, of which POSSIBLY half will be covered by insurance. Or maybe none. Would it be too obvious a pun to say that I'm speechless?]

It's funny, because on one level it SEEMED like it was a very positive meeting, and that everyone in the room was concerned about him and agreed that there were issues. But then there were all these red flag moments. Most red flaggish was the psychologist's immediate determination--without ever setting eyes on my kid--that he has social anxiety disorder and needs medication. "You have private insurance?" he kept asking me, over and over. "Because social anxiety falls under a MEDICAL issue, not an academic one..." He did mention once or twice ways in which he could help me navigate that part of the issue once/if N is 'in the special ed system,' which sounded like he thought he'd qualify SOMEWHERE. But he also said things that he clearly thought were going to be reassuring but were actually just obnoxious and condescending, such as, "We'll definitely be keeping an eye on N over the next couple of years to see how he's progressing." [Um, DAMNED STRAIGHT you will be. Because I'm going to be on your asses from here on out.] To me, statements like that are echoes of the preschool assessment, and are saying nothing more than, "We're going to deny you services again, but don't worry...We'll keep an eye on him, and when things are really messed up, THEN we'll step in. It may be too late by then, but we'll be there for ya!"

In the end, when I asked the psychologist point-blank if he was going to actually assess my kid he said no. "Again, these are really medical issues, which you need to address outside the district. You said you have private insurance?" In retrospect, I know that that's bullshit, and I'm thinking that what I might do is to sign the assessment plan (after all, I do want the OT and speech assessments, and I want them done NOW) but attach a note that says that I believe that the lack of social/emotional assessment will be detrimental to my child's overall progress and that not considering those issues will be setting him up for academic failure. (I have a huge book on special-ed law that a special-ed maven/friend of mine from the school loaned me, and it will only take a short while for me to be able to cite chapter and verse from it with regards to their responsibilities in this arena. We'll see how I feel when I get the official version of the plan from the school.)

There was also a lot of commenting about how smart N is. Which, again...Sounds nice until you remember that these people tend to base--or try to base--their decisions on academics. And if he's doing OK in class...then what's the big worry? Luckily, his teacher was fairly vocal on the ways in which his emotional issues (she called them self-esteem problems, which breaks my heart, but again...I'm not going to complain about the verbiage. I just want results) are affecting him in the classroom. So you'd think that's good, but...I don't see where this assessment is going to deal with that. Unless the district OT program is a good, broad one that goes well beyond working with him to cut a straight line and draw a recognizable human figure. Which, if you know school districts, is so unlikely as to be freaking hilarious to even consider.

Like I said, I got a feeling that everyone (except maybe the psychologist) thinks there are problems, and thinks he needs help. I got this feeling especially from the speech therapist, who I just...I don't know. She seems really smart, and she seems to get what I'm talking about--she was the one who had referred him to the preschool assessment team back in 1995 because she thought he needed to be evaluated for an ASD (autism spectrum disorder). But at the same time, she seems desperate to NOT be the one to help me. So she did a lot of telling me how she didn't think he was going to qualify for speech, but at the same time kept making clucking noises about how he seems to have sensory integration issues ("Make sure he gets an OT assessment," she kept saying to the special ed teacher who was leading the meeting) and how the fine motor delays he seems to have ("See why he needs that OT assessment?" she said again) fall into the same sort of category with the sensory issues, and how that could affect speech...BUT that she thinks his articulation falls within reasonable levels. Which...she might as well have just said, "Look, I think he needs help, but I'm swamped as the only speech therapist for like three or four area schools, and I'm doing whatever I can to avoid having new kids assigned to me unless they're mute." At least then I would have known where I stood, right?

My favorite moment (and by favorite I mean the moment I most felt like hurting someone but was glad I held off when I watched their faces as I spoke) was when the special ed teacher, noting my not-so-positive response to the idea of getting N into the care of psychiatrist for social anxiety, said to me, "I know how you feel about medicating a child; many of us would feel the same way. But, really, if you think about it, if he had diabetes..."

I didn't even let her get CLOSE to finishing that sentence before I cut her off. Now, mind you, I was smiling through this whole meeting, from start to finish--friendly and eager to please and almost physically incapable of being truly contentious, even knowing that what I really want is for them to fear me. (Shit, I actually volunteered to edit the school's reapplication for California Distinguished School status--I worked on the original, successful app four years ago--while we were waiting for the speech therapist and N's teacher to arrive. Eager to be liked, much?) So what I said probably didn't sound as harsh in person as it does here. Or maybe it does. "Listen," I said. "I've written about mental health...I've written a *book* on mental health, on bipolar disorder, and I USED that EXACT example. I WROTE that exact example. I get it. But I'm not putting my kid on drugs until I'm absolutely certain that I've exhausted all the other avenues--and until I'm certain that that's the problem. And I'm not certain of either." And I smiled sweetly. And she shut up.

But it was a small victory in a day of what felt like much larger...non victories? I don't know. I think that's the worst part of this process. Being new to it all, I don't know where the traps are. I don't know what victory looks like. I don't know what failure looks like. I don't know what I did or did not achieve today, and I don't know how what I did or did not do, said or did not say, is going to affect what happens in two months from now, when we have our actual IEP meeting. I've gotten tons of fabulous advice about dealing with special ed, much of it from people reading this blog, but almost none of it was able to help me make heads or tails of the subtle undercurrents of what was going on in that room today between the five of them and the one of me--the only one focused solely on the needs of the little boy watching Spongebob and waiting for Mommy to come home and help him do his homework on odd and even numbers and quiz him for his spelling test on Friday.

Friday, October 5, 2007

B...b....but...

Just a quick post to ask: Can anyone out there explain to me why I just stuttered like crazy through a two-minute message left on a speech therapist's voice mail...even though I DON'T NORMALLY STUTTER...?

Well, maybe he'll think there's a strong family history of speech issues and get back to me more quickly, right?

(This guy's a referral from our pediatrician, who saw Em yesterday--lump on her jaw...don't ask...it's OK now--and got RIGHT ON IT when I told her I was floundering in trying to find a good--i.e., not just from the phone book--SLP who deals with kids over the age of 5 and has an office less than an hour from my house. We'll see what happens.)

Thursday, October 4, 2007

Burst bubble


[N, putting, at the gorgeous-beyond-belief children's golf academy where he takes lessons]

I was doing my Thursday-in-the-first-grade-classroom activity--distributing the week's marked-up work into folders for each individual child--when I noticed that almost all of N's work from class, especially anything involving language arts, had a "with help" written on it. I decided it was probably time to ask the teacher for a sit-down, just to check in on how N is really doing. I've been buoyed by watching him really 'get stuff' when he does his homework, and by watching what seem to be his blossoming social skills in a variety of different social situations, like his golf class and at Hebrew school, etc., but I still wanted to check in to make sure this wasn't a real issue, and to maybe ask the teacher about how she thinks his speech is.

By the time I was done with my 'job', the class was outside having recess. As I approached, N came over from the bench where he was still working on his snack. All the other kids were on the playground. Suddenly, his teacher appeared:

"Mrs. Confused! Thanks for all your help today. I do have a favor to ask of you, though...N, would you please go clean up your snack so I can talk to Mommy?"

Uh-oh. "Yes?"

"Um, could you maybe work with N on getting him to join the other children to play during recess? This is my first time on yard duty this year, and I hadn't realized, but he doesn't play with the other kids. And when I ask him to go play, he sometimes refuses. I can insist he go out there, and I do, but then he just stands on the sidelines as a bystander, sucking his thumb, and..."

I hold up my hand. "Funny you should bring this up. I was coming out here to ask if we could set up a time..."

"...for a conference? Oh, good. I was hoping we would get to talk before the end of the first marking period."

"Yes. I was wanting to talk to you about his classwork, but also to get your input on some other things. For instance, I'm planning to take him to get a speech..."

"Oh, I've already asked several times for the speech therapist to do an assessment on him, and she says he's already on her list, but she hasn't gotten to him yet."

This was followed by a not-worth-recording conversation about how to make that happen more quickly, and another on how she (teacher) should not for a second think that I (mother) am not aware of any of these issues, etc. And then I left. And even though I was the one who was going out there to talk to HER...I felt totally deflated. I guess I was hoping that we would just talk about how he's having trouble following directions, but otherwise he's just fine! Totally normally! All the kids love him! Nothing to see here, you over-involved, worry-wart mom!

But, instead, I got: He has really obvious social issues. I got: I told the speech therapist I thought it was important for him to get help RIGHT AWAY! I got: I'm so glad you want to talk about this because I think it's important to work on these issues RIGHT AWAY! Time's a'wastin'! This kid isn't going to get any better just because you wish it away, you know! (OK. Maybe that last one wasn't so much verbatim, but it was clearly her point.)

What it really comes down to is that instead of, "Yeah, I see what you're saying, and you're right, but I hadn't really been thinking about it much because it's just not that big of a deal," I got, "I've clearly been thinking about this a lot, and acting on it, too, and I just wasn't sure yet how and when to bring it up to you, but it's big and it's obvious, and he may be looking better to you these days, but to me, meeting him for the first time, I see deficits, and they're glaring, and you really do need to do deal with them." And that's depressing.

I've been down this road a minimum of 76 times before, of course. Most of you have read it; most of you are doubtless tired of reading it and having it go nowhere. You know those times...where I get all het up to do xyz to help N, where I recognize that there's a problem, but then I start to see progress and start to wonder if I'm overreacting, only to have The World slap me in the face and say, "No! You're not overreacting! Progress does not mean over and done with. How many times do I have to tell you? GET HIM HELP." You'd think that by now...

Once the letter to the school district--the one I just finished writing--is received, they have two weeks to do the assessment. But (I know, I know) that likely won't be enough, so I'll get an outside SLP appointment set up, too. I was hoping to wait until after the likely-to-be-combined hernia-and-testicle surgery to do it, but that may not work out, since he still needs to be seen by a general surgeon before we can even schedule that. And that may take more time than, it turns out, I should let slip past. Already, it's been nearly 7 years...or, to be fair to myself, between 4 and 5 years since I first noticed a problem. Perhaps it's time to stop waiting for 'the right time.'

---
BTW, on a completely unrelated note, today is Baroy's birthday. 52. He's so OLD! But I love him anyway. Happy birthday, hubby mine.

Friday, September 14, 2007

What he said when I asked him

Several of you asked me, apropos of my last post, what N said when I asked him about his ostensibly odd response to the 'favorite number' question.

Truth is, I hadn't asked him at all at first; I didn't want him to think he'd done it 'wrong' or that I was disappointed with him. But when you all pointed out the 2+6=8 thing--despite the fact that I know my kid, and I know that's not the way he thinks--I had to check to be sure. And so I went to him and asked, and it turns out you guys were about half right. Or at least meg was about half right when she said that maybe he thought your favorite number had to be between 1 and 10--except, as N explained to me, somewhat circuitously, the favorite number had to be between 1 and 20.

"Oh," I said, "so you couldn't have 26 as your favorite number, then."

"Right."

"So why did you say your favorite number was 8? How did you come up with the number 8?"

"Because I like it."

"But why? Does it have anything to do with number 26?"

"I like it because Emmy used to be 8. Before she was 9 and 10."

Yeeeeeeah. Like I said, not the way he thinks. But I will admit, it would have been really cool if you were right and I could say things like, "Well, the reason I can't understand what he's saying is because he's just TOO SMART FOR ME."

(Don't say it, you. I know you were about to.)

Thursday, September 13, 2007

Pragmatics, Part III

There couldn't be a clearer example of what I am trying to talk about here than the one handed to me at Back to School Night last night.

After N's teacher had finished her shpiel, she invited us to look around at some of the work the kids have done just in these past seven days of school. On the back wall, papers were stapled to a bulletin board, each filled out by a different child in the class. The kids filled in the blanks in the following sentence: My favorite number is __ because __________.

Most of the kids had written similar statements:

"My favorite number is 6, because I am 6."

"My favorite number is 9, because my sister is 9."

"My favorite number is 20, because that is when I'm going to get married." (Hee! That one just slayed me. And, for the record, it was written by N's Loving Girl, whose mom took one look at the paper, covered her eyes with her hands, and waved me off when I came over to gently mock her. "I know, I know," she sighed. "I don't even know what to say.")

Clearly, a bunch of the kids had...well, let's say maybe they borrowed from each other. Or maybe the teacher suggested specific ideas for how to decide on your favorite number. Whatever the case, there were at least a half dozen statements on the order of "My favorite number is 12 because I was born on July 12" and "My favorite number is 3 because I was born on April 3."

And then there was N's: "My favorite number is 8," he wrote, "because I was born on January 26."

What the...?

The thing is, it would be hilarious if it weren't so messed up. Or maybe it would be messed up if it weren't so hilarious. But whatever it is, it's a pretty clear example of what I mean when I say that sometimes he just doesn't...just CAN'T...make sense.

[Also at Back to School Night was a one-on-one conversation about how the teacher wants to work on getting N to stop sucking his thumb at school because she fears he's going to get teased by the other kids. More on that another time, but for now, let me just say: Iceberg? Meet tip.]

Thursday, August 30, 2007

Contradictions

Green, first off, I'll NEVER complain about a comment. I want comments. Hell, I LUST after comments. Nothing would make me happier than to get 73 bajillion comments on a single post, like some people I know [coughJanecough]. I'd be happy even if some of them were to piss me off. Which yours DID NOT. So, not to worry. Promise.

-------
Kristen mentioned a possible language processing disorder being behind what I've been calling N's pragmatics problem. I started looking at that possibility, and hit the same old wall that I always hit when talking about N: The kid is an enormous mass of contradictions.

The initial reason we started worrying about him was his social skills (or complete lack thereof), and so we had his school district evaluate him, when he was almost 4.5 years old, to see if he might qualify for any kind of services. On the Batelle Developmental Inventory, he scored in the FIRST PERCENTILE on peer interaction. You can't score any lower than that. BUT, he got a 75th percentile score on adult interaction, putting his overall personal-social percentile at 30, which is in the normal range, thus allowing the school district to say no to services.

All of that is water under the bridge, and he did ultimately get some social skills therapy, and he'd probably score a lot better in peer interaction if tested today, though it's clearly still an issue. But my point is: contradiction. HUGE contradiction. First percentile; 75th percentile. It's not just that there's a difference in these different skills; that's to be expected. It's that the difference is so HUGE.

Same thing with his motor skills. This is a kid whose gross motor skills are, at least in some areas, not just fine, but remarkable. This is the kid who could throw and catch a ball at nine months, though he couldn't roll from front to back until *18* months of age, well after he was walking and running. Bizarre. This is the kid who could hit a pitched ball at age 2. This is the kid whose golf coaches are almost literally drooling over him. And yet, this is the kid who, at 6.5, still can't draw, has a hard time coloring in the lines, and whose scissor skills are pretty poor. Contradiction? To some degree.

And so it seems to be with processing. Most everything I'm reading seems to lump language and auditory processing together. In many ways, N's auditory skills are awesome. He's never had a problem understanding what is said to him, never had a problem following instruction. I also THINK he has a fairly advanced ability to take information and generalize it or draw conclusions from it--the problem is in his ability to express those generalizations and conclusions in a way that is understandable if you weren't the one to give him the initial information and thus know where he's drawing his seemingly bizarre sentences and phrases from.

In addition, his vocabulary is quite advanced for his age, even if he can't necessarily say all the words in an understandable form.

I dunno. I'm trying to find a speech and language pathologist in our area who would be covered by our insurance, at least for an eval, as you guys all suggested, both publicly and privately. I'll bring along the posts I'm collecting, and I'll also bring along the old reports, including the one from the developmental pediatrician we saw after the school district denied services--the one who seemed to think the social issues were secondary to language issues, and whose opinion I at that time pooh-poohed. Ah, hindsight, you 20-20 darlin'.

In looking it over, two years later, I can see that the same issues I'm talking about now were in evidence then: "N does not describe his daily experiences in logical sequence in any depth without significant prompts," she wrote. "He sometimes will ignore a question and talk about something unrelated to the topic at hand. N will often retreat into speaking 6-8 different babyish voices, more so at home or in the parents' presence than at school...N also demonstrates a somewhat immature speech pattern and exhibits some frustration when he is not understood correctly..."

I would make some "the more things change the more they stay the same" comment here, except nothing has changed. So...onward.

Tuesday, August 28, 2007

Pragmatics, Part II

"I'm changing the channel," N says.

"Why, don't you like this show?" I ask.

"I do, but I don't like this show. I hate it a lot."

This is what I'm talking about: I do, but I don't. The repetition of "I don't like it/I hate it", by the way, doesn't mean anything. Tomorrow, he may tell me he loves this show, or that it's his favorite. But that, I think, is a more common issue: N changes his mind all the time; he's totally arbitrary. But when you contradict yourself within the same sentence...that seems to me to be something else. Something about not knowing how to say what you mean.

Sunday, August 26, 2007

Pragmatics, Part I

I'm gearing up to push, this year, for someone, somewhere, to start helping N with some of his language problems. His pediatrician wrote a note to the school recommending a speech evaluation, and several of my very-learned-and-astute-in-this-arena friends have strongly suggested the same.

My concerns are that, in a school district that has ignored me at every step, his literal 'speech' issues are not serious or severe enough to warrant speech therapy or other services. But that's only if you ignore, as school districts tend to do, language (focusing only on speech) and pragmatics (focusing only on diction). Because, MAYBE, if he's in the mood to speak clearly, you can understand most of what he says...if he's reading words out of a book, say. But when he speaks on his own, half the time it's not the sounds that are the problem, it's the words. Or, rather, it's the sentences. They're mixed up and backwards. Sometimes they're outright inside out. Most of the time they require you to either know the context of what he's talking about, or to know his speech quirks...like the fact that he sometimes mixes up opposites, so that yes can literally mean no and vice versa.

But it's impossible to explain this without examples. And it's even harder to explain it to a school district or, if that doesn't work out, a private speech therapist. Which is why, a while ago, I started keeping track of some of these 'quirks' in N's language; I was making a list of solid examples that would make my concerns clearer. Except, um, I seem to have lost it. Don't ask.

For the next little while, then, I'm going to try to write them down here, because I can't lose the internet, right? (Well, I probably *can*, but I'd have to try a lot harder than I did with that yellow pad of mine.) So, if you're not interested in the weird language quirks of a 6-and-a-half-year-old about-to-enter-first-grade boy, feel free to ignore any and all future installments of this sort of thing, which I'll call Pragmatics (so I can find it more easily).

Here is the sentence that prompted me to do this tonight, right now; the one he said to me not five minutes ago:

"What time I want to brush my teeth?"

(Translation: When do I HAVE to brush my teeth? Not only is the "What time I want" part just clunky and awkward and missing the word 'do', but the 'I want' is 'wrong'; he was trying to find out if he could WAIT to brush his teeth, because he didn't want to brush them or, more specifically, to go to bed, which is what directly follows brushing. He was very much NOT saying he wanted to brush his teeth. Except, of course, that's what he DID say. And, because I knew this, I was able to just answer, "You have to brush your teeth right now." Almost anyone else would have just stared at him in bewilderment.)

So that's today's installment. To those of you still here, thanks for listening. And deciphering. And caring.